As of recently, several states in the US passed laws requiring schools to enforce stricter phone policies. This policy restricts students and staff from using their phone during class time, dictating that they have to put their phones away and silenced at all times. Although this policy can benefit students’ focus and education, many are concerned for their safety. Strictness and rules can vary depending on the district. Some schools are very lenient and allow students to go on their phone during breaks. In contrast, other schools lock up students’ phones in bags that only security can unlock, ensuring that phones won’t be used until the end of the day. Many teachers are in favor of this policy because it eliminates any distractions from class and they’re able to teach properly, but students feel otherwise.
Something that comes with being connected with the internet is being aware of what’s happening around the world. Students are on their phones for more than just texting and taking selfies. They’re constantly keeping themselves updated with news inside and outside of where they live, giving them a sense of security and cognizance.
On March 7 of this year, Eleanor Roosevelt High School received a school shooting threat. Word spread quickly through the use of phones and technology. Because of the school shootings that happened in the US in previous years, staff and students are concerned for their safety and want to stay updated or even go home.
Naomi Jhu, a JV player on the ERHS volleyball teams shares their opinion on the new phone policy, “If they don’t have their phone, they don’t know what’s happening,” Says Jhu.
Students feel as if provoking their phones is also provoking their safety, and many agree that this policy has been taken too far in certain states. Although they understand the reason for the phone ban, they think that locking up phones until the end of the day is completely unnecessary and unrealistic, and it steps past the initial purpose.
Ghaleb Jaber, a Unity ambassador at ERHS shares, “I think that phone policies are given to make sure students stay on track but I don’t think phone bags are the solution we are looking for,” Says Jaber.
“I think that the main issues with the phone bags are the logistics behind it, it’s hard to manage a system like that. Especially with such a big campus and students with different schedules,” Jaber added.
